Bill of 10 November: up to 10% of the digital ad budget of advertisers spending over 1M€ redirected to online news sites. What it changes for a scale-up, and how to buy it.
Yesterday, 10 November, the French government presented to the Council of Ministers a bill that obliges any advertiser spending more than one million euros a year on advertising to direct a share of its digital investment to the websites of general and political news publishers. The share will be set by decree, capped at 10%. The same day, Jean-Luc Chetrit, managing director of the Union des marques, the French advertisers' association, resigned from the presidency of the ACPM, the body that measures press audiences, with a sentence reported by The Media Leader: "This decision is neither personal nor circumstantial." If you run a funded scale-up spending more than a million on media in France, this text concerns you. My view fits in two lines. The principle is bad: a media plan is not decided by decree. But the medium itself is good, and under-bought. And I would rather you bought online news because you decided to, not because your statutory auditor asks you to.
Advertising redirection: what the text says
The Ministry of Culture's release is short. It speaks of a "major economic crisis" for traditional media, of advertising resources that "have been falling continuously for more than a decade" and of market value "increasingly captured by digital platforms". The remedy: an "obligation", on the main public and private advertisers, to direct "a limited fraction of their online advertising budgets" to digital general and political news publishers. Threshold: one million euros of annual advertising spend. And according to The Media Leader, which read the draft revealed by Contexte at the end of September, the threshold also applies at group level, cumulative spend. No way around it by splitting subsidiaries.
The rest comes from the journalists who read the text, since the release does not say it: a dedicated section in the annual management report, checked by the statutory auditor where there is one, and a fine of up to 75,000 euros, for the company or its executive. Le Figaro, quoted by Quartz, mentions around 3,000 advertisers concerned and some 150 million euros for the press, "under certain assumptions". The Alliance de la presse d'information générale wants a vote before February 2027, when Parliament suspends its work for the presidential election. And a second text already exists: on 2 November, MPs adopted at first reading of the 2027 budget an amendment by general rapporteur Philippe Juvin, creating a tax of 0.5% of revenue for advertisers above one million, from which they are exempt if they redirect up to 15% of their digital spend to news publishers. Two texts, two caps, one direction.
Why I am against the principle
I make my living building media plans, and I have never seen a good plan come out of an imposed percentage. Chetrit is right when he says, in The Media Leader, that spending decided by law "amounts to an earmarked contribution, a tax", and that "you do not solve a real demand problem by punishing those who keep buying". The figures he puts against it are Kantar Media's for the Union des marques: large advertisers have broadly maintained their support for the press, and it is the long tail of small advertisers that has dropped off, 179 million euros less in five years according to him. The text does not touch them. It touches the 3,000 who still buy.
The first-half BUMP, published by France Pub, IREP and Kantar Media, gives the context. The press, digital included, posts 582 million euros of net revenue, down 6%, in a market of 9.753 billion growing 5.6%. Digital display, for its part, reaches 1.25 billion, up 10.3%. And a Senate report, quoted by AFP, estimates that the large platforms took 76% of the French online advertising market in 2025, 9.4 billion out of 12.4. The problem is real. But the answer sets a precedent: if the State can redirect 10% of your digital to the press, tomorrow it can redirect a share to radio or television, which are also falling and which the text excludes. Loïc Riviere, in his Journal du Net column, sees discrimination between media and a risk of conflict with article 21 of the European Media Freedom Act. I add a buyer's argument: a constrained advertiser buys badly. He takes the simplest pipe, the open auction, and Pierre Petillault, managing director of the Alliance, acknowledges it himself in The Media Leader: in this "opaque" market, two intermediaries take most of the growth. Chetrit draws the conclusion: "One could imagine the platforms being the beneficiaries of this measure." A law for the press whose margin ends up in adtech: that is what redirection without method produces.
Why I am for the medium
Now turn the problem around. Step out of the bill and look at the inventory. Online news is an editorial context you choose, an audience that reads rather than scrolls, and a setting where nobody bids against you with the budget of an e-commerce giant. I wrote ten days ago that the price of a Meta ad rose 14% in a year for an audience growing 3%. Kantar Media counts 22,707 advertisers in the press in the broad sense; there were 51,474 in digital over the same half. A counter where the queue is half as long is a counter where you negotiate. And there is an argument press sales houses do not use enough: when I look at the sources ChatGPT or Perplexity cite on our clients' queries, news sites come up again and again. When I explained why Reddit is the medium ChatGPT cites, the logic was the same: be present, in advertising and in content, where AI goes to find its answers. Online news is search and GEO by another road.
What it means for a scale-up, order of magnitude, and the arithmetic is mine: 2 million euros of media a year, of which 1.4 million digital. With the 10% cap, that is 140,000 euros a year on news sites, a little under 12,000 euros a month. That is not a line that endangers your CAC. It is the budget of a serious test, provided you do not buy it like a fine.
My rule for buying online news, decree or no decree
One, I do not wait for the text: I take 10% of my digital now and place it myself, because a budget placed before the law is negotiated, and a budget placed under the law is endured. Two, I deal direct or in programmatic guaranteed with three or four publishers, never in open auction: the premium of a redirection must not end up with intermediaries. Three, I choose the context as I would choose a screen: business and tech sections for a fintech, regional press around catchment areas for a store network, trade titles for a B2B offer. Four, I measure my own way, brand searches and direct traffic in the exposed zone against a control zone, never the publisher's report. And I cap it: one quarter, one budget, three publishers, then we decide.
Who should prepare now
Fintechs and post-Series A scale-ups. They cross the million very quickly, and their audience reads the business press. On Deblock, we delivered more than 30 million impressions by surrounding the metro and geotargeting mobile within 100 metres: the reasoning holds for online news. You buy the sections your future customers pass through, not "the press".
Networks and retail. Regional daily press is the most natural local medium for drive-to-store. On Comptoirs de la Bio, isochrone targeting around the stores halved the budget compared with leaflets, 100% tracked. The same logic, zone by zone, applies to regional news sites. It is the type of network we are currently working with at Banette, a network of artisan bakeries, on its digital strategy and social activations: for a network, local online news is reasoned zone by zone, like the rest of the plan. Read our drive-to-store geomarketing method, it transfers as is.
B2B. On Medical Pro, acquiring radiologists and doctors was built on LinkedIn and on content. Online trade titles play the same role for other professions. And when redirection arrives, those who already have their contracts and native formats will negotiate; the others will buy what is left.
Those who should stay out of the debate, not the medium. Below a million in spend, the text does not concern you. Nothing stops you testing online news with a budget under 10,000 euros a month, in bursts, in one zone.
What I tell founders
The text can still change. The threshold, the cap, the fine, everything will be debated, and the parliamentary calendar before a presidential election is what it is. But look at the direction: a draft revealed in September, an amendment voted on 2 November, a bill on the 10th, and a tax of 0.5% of revenue waiting in the budget if redirection fails. For a scale-up with 40 million in revenue, 0.5% is 200,000 euros, my arithmetic, not the Treasury's: the order of magnitude of what you would have put into the press anyway. So you are going to buy online news, one way or another. The only question left is whether you buy it as a line in a media plan, with a context, a negotiated price and a measurement, or as a line in the management report. I have already explained why I have my clients pay media owners directly; that is exactly what will allow you, when the day comes, to prove to the auditor what was redirected, and to whom. The media mix simulator gives you a first order of magnitude of what 10% of your digital represents. And if you want to know which publishers, which sections and at what price, for your brand, that is the work I do during a free audit.